Back to Thoughts

Twenty Months, Five Cases, No Consequences

June 28, 2026

Five incidents. Twenty months. Different actors, different regions, different institutions. Same ending.

August 2025: The DPR Housing Allowance

580 members of parliament from the 2024–2029 period began receiving a Rp 50 million monthly housing allowance starting October 2024. Ten times Jakarta’s minimum wage at the time. Total disbursement across all members: Rp 348 billion per year — on top of existing salary and benefit packages that civil society groups calculated could total Rp 230 million per member per month.1

When a BBC Indonesia report made the figures public, NasDem commission member Ahmad Sahroni responded to public outrage by calling the protesters “orang paling bodoh di dunia” — and said they “seharusnya masuk penjara.”2 The statement went viral. Protests began.

On August 28, 2025, during dispersal of a demonstration in Pejompongan, Jakarta, a Brimob armored vehicle struck and killed Affan Kurniawan — a 21-year-old ojol driver delivering food nearby. He was not a protester.3 The incident ignited unrest across the country. Legislative buildings and police stations burned in Makassar, Pontianak, and Blitar. Seven people died across the protests.4

President Prabowo convened party leaders and announced the housing allowance would be cancelled. He simultaneously claimed the protests showed “signs of treason and terrorism” — without presenting evidence.5

What happened next: Allowance cancelled under street pressure. The Brimob officers involved in Affan’s death were referred to internal ethics review. No criminal prosecution was filed.

August 2025: Wamenaker Arrested in a Rp 81 Billion Extortion Scheme

On August 20, 2025, the KPK arrested Deputy Minister of Manpower Immanuel Ebenezer (“Noel”) in a sting operation.6 The ministry’s Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health certification unit had been running an extortion scheme since 2019: companies seeking K3 certification were deliberately delayed unless they paid bribes. Eleven suspects were named. Total estimated flow: Rp 81 billion. Noel’s alleged cut: Rp 3 billion.7

Earlier in 2025, the same minister had publicly told young Indonesians participating in the #KaburAjaDulu wave: “Mau kabur, kabur sajalah, kalau perlu jangan balik lagi.”8

What happened next: Prabowo signed a presidential decree removing Noel within days of the arrest. He was the first Prabowo cabinet member arrested on corruption charges.

January 2025 – June 2026: MBG Poisoned 37,000 Children. Then Its Leadership Stole From It.

The Makan Bergizi Gratis program — Prabowo’s flagship policy targeting 82.9 million beneficiaries at a 2026 budget of Rp 268 trillion — began distributing meals in January 2025.9

By April 2026, the JPPI had documented 37,673 cases of suspected food poisoning across 210 districts in 31 provinces. 2,348 required hospitalization.10

At the same time, public scrutiny of procurement revealed irrational budget items: 21,801 electric motorcycles at Rp 42 million each. Rp 6.9 billion for field socks. A Zoom license at Rp 5.7 billion for nine months — more than ten times the market rate. Rp 1.2 trillion in IT equipment.11

On June 3, 2026, the Attorney General’s Office arrested BGN chief Dadan Hindayana and his two deputies, Sony Sonjaya and Lodewyk Pusung — a retired two-star general personally appointed by Prabowo.12 The charges: selling SPPG operating licenses to unqualified foundations in exchange for kickbacks, and marking up procurement prices. Sony, as justice collaborator, subsequently named 41 individuals involved.13

The MBG corruption case became the first in Indonesian history to involve a designated National Strategic Project.

What happened next: Three officials arrested. Prabowo appointed new BGN leadership the day before the arrests — a sequencing that implies the prosecution was known in advance and managed. Civil society coalition MBG Watch filed a judicial review at the Constitutional Court.14 No structural reform of the program’s governance has been announced.

June 15, 2026: Officials Evacuated by Police from a University Campus

A discussion titled “Pancasila as the Unifier of the Nation” was held at Universitas Gadjah Mada’s Innovation Center, organized by a political media group affiliated with the ruling coalition. Deputy Agriculture Minister Sudaryono and political figure Budiman Sudjatmiko were among the speakers.15

Students present questioned why political officials were the designated speakers for a Pancasila-themed academic forum. After the session, students blocked the exit and confronted the delegation. Police evacuated Sudaryono, Budiman, and other officials using patrol vehicles as students pursued them.16

What happened next: No action taken against the students. No statement from the university. Sudaryono denied he fled.

June 13–26, 2026: A Doctor Was Intimidated by Drunk Legislators for Doing Her Job. She Died Two Weeks Later.

Dr. Eliza Princila Utami Pakaenoni — dr. Icha, 27 — was on duty at the IGD of RS Leona Kefamenanu, NTT, treating a 19-year-old snakebite patient referred from RSUD Kefamenanu. The patient was the nephew of DPRD TTU member Therensius Lazakar.17

Following standard SOP, dr. Icha administered the treatment indicated by the consulting specialist and declined to provide a specific vaccine that was both medically unwarranted and out of stock.

Two DPRD members — Lazakar (Golkar) and Norbertus Tubani (PKB) — entered the IGD and shouted at dr. Icha. Tubani pointed at her and announced his position: “Catat saya. Saya anggota DPRD TTU Komisi III yang bermitra dengan Dinas Kesehatan.” A family member later told reporters what else was said: “Kau akan ketemu saya di Komisi III.”18

Dr. Icha was hospitalized for severe depression for six days starting June 15. After discharge on June 21, she continued outpatient care. She was found dead in her room on June 26, 2026.19

She was a specialist in snakebite treatment — a rare expertise in a region where snakebite deaths are common.

What happened next: The NTT Governor expressed anger. The Health Ministry deployed an inspection team. Both DPRD members denied intimidation. As of this writing, no criminal arrest has been made.20

The Pattern

The two cases where prosecution appeared — Noel, BGN — share a specific quality: both men had already become political liabilities before enforcement moved. Both were replaced by the same executive who appointed them. The cycle closed on itself.

The cases where nothing happened share a different quality: no faction benefits from accountability. The DPR members who called protesters idiots kept their seats. The DPRD legislators who walked into an emergency room and left a specialist dead have not been detained.

Indonesia does not lack laws. It lacks consequences for the people enforcement would cost something to pursue.

What Happens Next

Research on democratic erosion identifies a consistent downstream effect of sustained elite impunity: legitimacy transfer. When citizens repeatedly observe that the law applies selectively, they don’t become more law-abiding — they stop believing in the law’s neutrality entirely.21 Trust doesn’t erode gradually. It collapses in episodes, each one triggered by a visible incident that confirms what people already suspected.

Cornell’s research on democratic backsliding names “elite collusion” — where incumbents, allied officials, and corporate leaders co-opt opposition through patronage — as one of two primary pathways to democratic collapse globally, and cites Indonesia explicitly as an example of this pattern already underway.22

The clearest regional parallel is Thailand. Between 2001 and 2014, Thailand ran the same cycle on a faster clock: popular governments, elite impunity, street protest, official capitulation, no structural accountability. Each resolution without consequence made the next incident more likely and the public more radicalized. The cycle didn’t stabilize — it escalated until the military had sufficient justification to end the cycle permanently, staging coups in 2006 and 2014.23 Thailand has not had a clean democratic election since.

The mechanism is not that impunity causes coups. The mechanism is that impunity hollows out the arguments for working within the system. When enough people — on the street and inside institutions — conclude that the rules don’t apply to the people making them, the rules stop functioning as rules. What replaces them is either strongman order or disorder, and one of those is always on offer.

Indonesia in 2026 is not Thailand in 2013. But the distance is shorter than it looks from inside a news cycle.24

These incidents are sourced from Indonesian news media including Kompas, Detik, Tribunnews, and official government statements. All facts are as reported at time of writing, June 2026.

References

Footnotes

  1. Forum Indonesia untuk Transparansi Anggaran (Fitra) calculated DPR member take-home pay could reach Rp 230 million per month based on DIPA data for 2023–2025. Total housing allowance for 580 members: Rp 348 billion annually. Source: FITRA, IDN Times reporting, August 2025. ↩

  2. Ahmad Sahroni, Deputy Chairman of Commission III (NasDem), made the statement during a working visit to North Sumatra Police on August 22, 2025. Source: Kompas, August 26, 2025. ↩

  3. Affan Kurniawan, 21, was killed on August 28–29, 2025 (accounts vary on the date by one day depending on source) when a Brimob armored vehicle struck him near Pejompongan during protest dispersal. He was delivering a food order at the time. Source: Kompas.tv, August 30, 2025. ↩

  4. Per Wikipedia’s documented entry on the August–September 2025 Indonesia unrest, seven civilians died across the protests nationally. Buildings burned included the Makassar DPRD complex and multiple police posts. Source: Wikipedia “Unjuk rasa dan kerusuhan Indonesia Agustus–September 2025.” ↩

  5. Prabowo made the “makar dan terorisme” claim at a press conference following the party leaders meeting, per reporting from multiple outlets including Kompas and DPR’s own Jdih documentation. Source: Kompas, September 2025. ↩

  6. KPK OTT of Immanuel Ebenezer confirmed by KPK Deputy Chairman Fitroh Rohcahyanto on August 20, 2025. Source: JambiLink.id, August 21, 2025. ↩

  7. Total estimated extortion flow from Kemenaker K3 certification scheme: Rp 81 billion. Noel’s alleged personal share: Rp 3 billion. Eleven suspects named. Source: Antara News Sulteng, kilas balik kasus korupsi era Prabowo. ↩

  8. Noel’s “mau kabur, kabur sajalah, kalau perlu jangan balik lagi” statement was made in February 2025 in response to the #KaburAjaDulu trend. Source: JambiLink.id biographical profile, August 2025. ↩

  9. MBG budget of Rp 268 trillion for 2026 and 82.9 million beneficiary target per Badan Gizi Nasional official data as of May 2026. Launch date: January 6, 2025. Source: Info Pendidikan BIC, June 2026. ↩

  10. JPPI (Jaringan Pemantau Pendidikan Indonesia) documented 37,673 food poisoning cases across 210 districts in 31 provinces from early 2025 through April 7, 2026. 2,348 required hospitalization. Source: Info Pendidikan BIC citing JPPI data, June 2026. ↩

  11. Procurement irregularities documented by public scrutiny and Kompas reporting: 21,801 electric motorcycles at Rp 42 million each; Rp 6.9 billion field socks allocation; Zoom license at Rp 5.7 billion for April–December 2026; Rp 1.2 trillion IT equipment. Source: Kompas.id, “Kisah Kejatuhan Dadan Hindayana,” June 2026. ↩

  12. Dadan Hindayana, Sony Sonjaya, and Lodewyk Pusung arrested and named suspects by Kejaksaan Agung on June 3, 2026. Prabowo dismissed all three on June 2. Lodewyk Pusung: retired Mayjen TNI, former Pangdam I/Bukit Barisan, personally appointed by Prabowo as Wakil Kepala BGN on October 22, 2024. Source: Detik, Hukumonline, June 2026. ↩

  13. Sony Sonjaya applied for justice collaborator status and named 41 individuals involved, expanding from an initial 26. Source: KBK News, “Mahfud MD: Koruptor Kasus MBG Layak Dihukum Mati,” June 2026. ↩

  14. MBG Watch coalition filed judicial review of UU APBN 2026 at Mahkamah Konstitusi citing procedural and fiscal irregularities in MBG appropriation. Source: Transparency International Indonesia statement, June 4, 2026. ↩

  15. “Kopdar Bareng Mas Dar” discussion organized by Total Politik at GIK UGM, June 15, 2026. Sudaryono (Wamentan) and Budiman Sudjatmiko among speakers. Source: Tribunnews, June 2026. ↩

  16. Students confronted officials after the event; police evacuated Sudaryono and others via patrol vehicles. Source: Tribunnews, “Diskusi di UGM Ricuh,” June 2026. ↩

  17. Chronology per Victor Manbait (dr. Icha’s uncle and family spokesperson): patient admitted June 13, 2026 at RS Leona Kefamenanu after snakebite. Patient is nephew of DPRD TTU member Therensius Lazakar. Source: RRI, Detik Bali, Kompas, June 2026. ↩

  18. First quote (“Catat saya…”) is verbatim from dr. Icha’s formal complaint to the DPRD TTU Badan Kehormatan, as reported by Koran Timor and NTT Hits, June 2026. Second quote (“Kau akan ketemu saya di Komisi III”) attributed to one of the legislators by family spokesperson Fabi Banase, as reported by Liputan6 and Beritasatu, June 27, 2026. Twenty-three witnesses prepared to testify legislators smelled of alcohol. Source: Pos-Kupang, Tribunnews, June 2026. ↩

  19. Dr. Icha hospitalized June 15–21, 2026 for severe depression. Found dead at family home in Baumata, Kupang on June 26, 2026 at 18:30 WITA. Source: Pos-Kupang, Tribunnews, June 2026. ↩

  20. NTT Governor Melki Laka Lena confirmed receipt of formal reports from family, IDI NTT, and RS Leona management. Kemenkes inspection team deployed. Both DPRD members denied intimidation in written statements. Source: Liputan6, June 2026. ↩

  21. Trevor Jackson, “No Consequences,” The Baffler, November 2022: “Repeated episodes of elite impunity can sediment over time, eventually producing crises of political legitimacy… If you think elites are doing terrible things and not being held accountable, you will probably begin to lose confidence in the legitimacy of government and the rule of law.” ↩

  22. Rachel Beatty Riedl, Cornell University / Mario Einaudi Center for International Studies, as cited in “Democratic decline a global phenomenon,” Cornell Chronicle, January 2024. Indonesia is named alongside Guatemala as an archetypal case of the “elite collusion” pathway to democratic erosion. ↩

  23. Thailand experienced coups in September 2006 and May 2014, both preceded by years of protest-impunity cycles. The 2013–2014 crisis was directly triggered by a blanket amnesty bill that would have protected officials responsible for killing protesters in 2010. Source: Wikipedia, “2013–2014 Thai political crisis”; Prachatai English, “Coups as Holidays or History,” October 2025. ↩

  24. The Thailand-Indonesia comparison is structural, not predictive. Indonesia has different civil society depth, electoral history, and military doctrine. The parallel is in the mechanism — impunity as legitimacy drain — not the endpoint. ↩

Share on LinkedIn
← Back to Thoughts